Competitive Intelligence

Tactical, Operational & Strategic Analysis of Markets, Competitors & Industries

Bonnie Hohhof

Businss lessons from The Office: Season 5 Episode 12

Ron Desi, a professor at the University of Baltimore Towson, just posted an interesting analysis of "The Office" episode where: "Dunder Mifflin corporate asked Michael to gather some information on a competitor in a potential new market. Michael and Dwight decide to go “undercover” and obtain competitive intelligence. Michael pretended to be a potential client while Dwight pretended to be an interested potential employee." "I’ll be asking my MGMT 600 class to deal with this ethical dilemma and I’m sure some will fall on the side of Michael and other will say that everything he did was wrong. What would you do given the same situation?"

http://ubtowsonmba.blogspot.com/2009/01/business-lessons-from-offic...

Reply to This

Replies to This Discussion

Hello, Bonnie, don't ask me where I've watched Prince Family Paper. It hasn't taken place at http://www.hulu.com/watch/54236/the-office-prince-family-paper recommended by Ron Desi because there I've got no more than the message "We're sorry, currently our video library can only be streamed within the United States". Never mind.

Well, whom do you regard the most culpable person in the episode Prince Family Paper? Your answer is "Dwight Schrute", I'm afraid. In my humble opinion the owner of that family business is the most culpable person. However, is he rally "a sucker"? I don't think so. He simply tries to do what the competitive nature of private industry tells him to do. According to him, the client list will help Michael to become the next top client of his ["You call any of them I trust you'll hear some good things" (12:17-12:21)]. Also his wife seems to be an eager (business) beaver when she lets Michael to shoot herself against a background of that map (10:28-10:49), which doesn't include classified information, I hope. ;-) Just Dwight at the beginning of the episode (00:04-01:24) proves himself what means to be alert to today's Competitive Intelligence. :-)

By the way, does Dwight watching that family business through his binoculars (04:28-04:59) remind you of another case of unprofessional behavior ["Racketeer Harney gives Derry (Kiley) a contract to hit Breech (Long), whose wife Connie (Francis) is a paraplegic. Derry meets Connie, helping her to play a bar jukebox. Sympathizing with Connie, Derry decides, for a price, to fake Breech's death by buying a mortuary corpse and staging an automobile smash-up. Derry expects Breech and Connie to abscond to Mexico City" ( http://www.imdb.com/title/tt0394022/plotsummary )]? My wife and I enjoyed Hitchcock's Blood Bargain at http://www.guba.com/watch/2000930589?duration_step=0&fields=23&... . Incidentally, who of us isn't charmed by that melody ( http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=O0Eo3t7n2lU ) played during Blood Bargain not only with the help of that bar jukebox?

Best,
Tad

Reply to This

Preparing myself to today's lecture ( http://geocities.com/eklezjastka/ester4w-2.html ) which I'll give to my Poznan University of Technology students ( http://fedcba.ning.com/group/bi ) in a lecture hall situated there ( http://www.ee.put.poznan.pl/Forum%20budownictwa/forum%202007.htm ), I cannot resist the temptation to use for educational purposes also my activity in CI ( http://competitiveintelligence.ning.com/profile/TadeuszLemanczyk ), i.e. also my reply to Bonnie Hohhof, and add to that first discussion thread ( http://fedcba.ning.com/group/bi/forum/topics/naturalna-potrzeba ) the file ( http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=k6dMKlF9eWU ) which appeared at YouTube several days later. Will it be another stimulus to reflection on "robust and ethical intelligence practices" ( http://competitiveintelligence.ning.com/forum/topics/ci-as-a-dark-a... )? I hope so.

Reply to This

We discuss there ( http://innovate-ideagora.ning.com/forum ) so much about using IT tools in active learning instructional strategies that I cannot resist the temptation to add also here the video Client Lists ( http://fedcba.ning.com/video/client-lists ) used today in one of the discussions at http://in.hdt.pl/index.php .

Reply to This

Bonnie - the link you posted no longer exists.

You can find Ron Desi's blog at http://rondesi.com/the-office/business-lessons-from-the-office-seas...

There are also several places you can watch the episode (although probably the best - hulu.com - is unfortunately not available outside the US)

Reply to This

RSS

Latest Activity

Roman V. Romachev added 2 discussions
41 minutes ago
Thanks Arik, very much appreciated indeed. I'll take a listen
15 hours ago
Digimind has several job openings in the CI field and on the vendor side (sales, marketing). More information may be found at http://www.digimind.com/cat/news/jobs For more details contact me.
yesterday
Nicolas Belhassen and Walter Zabaglio joined Competitive Intelligence
yesterday
Hüda Tuzlu and Annette Siegl are now friends
yesterday
on Wednesday
Inteligencia competitiva para los hablamos español o portugués. Inteligência competitiva para os que falamos português ou espanhol
on Wednesday
on Wednesday
Walter, I can answer this one. Ok, first "big data" players usually means HP, Oracle, SAP, IBM. These firms are extraordinarily good at handling structured data (ie numbers) in relational databases, but they don't deal well with unstructured data,…
on Tuesday
Oh, they are doing CI, lots of it, but they call it other things, like Data mining e.g. They solve many of the same problems but from an engineering perspective Klaus
on Tuesday
Walter Zabaglio added a discussion
I've been turning this one over and can't find a satisfactory explanation. Why don't we see more 'big data' players doing CI consulting.  It seems to me that companies like Google, with absurdly comprehensive environmental data, doing more to move…
on Tuesday
Walter Zabaglio and Arik Johnson are now friends
on Tuesday
Arik Johnson Today is the last day to sign up for Wisconsin's Do-Not-Call list http://ping.fm/Styxi
on Tuesday
Tak Takasu and Nate Marlar are now friends
on Tuesday
on Monday
Hey Eric, Very nice, I really like your critical dissection of the author's convoluted and ultimately flawed, thought process which you laid out very articulately. Precisely right, what exactly is the difference here? The issue of direct vs indirec…
on Monday
An event by Andrew Beurschgens was featured
September 16, 2010 from 6pm to 9pm
A Case Study focused on “Smart Grid” Development in China ‘The Battle for China’s Smart Grid’ was a public strategy game run on both sides of the Atlantic by Fuld & Company. It was fascinating to observe European and US perspectives on the Chinese…
on Monday
An event by Rainer Michaeli was featured
ICI-1 - Competitive Intelligence Basics Workshop at Best Western Brandywine Valley Inn
September 9, 2010 at 9am to September 10, 2010 at 6pm
Achieving competitive advantage through systematic competitor and market analysis In times of increasing competition and complex, fast-moving competitive environments, it is important to be one step ahead of the competition. Businesses have to anti…
on Monday
Bill, I'm having trouble imagining you being pilloried for posting jobs during a global recession. I hope we have lots of trouble of this sort coming!
on Monday
So, to take this author's point: Gathering, analyzing and disseminating information sponsored by a major media source financed directly by a combination of pharma, oil, and automotive companies: ethically honorable. Gathering, analyzing and dissem…
on Monday

© 2010   Created by Arik Johnson.

Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Terms of Service

Sign in to chat!